Guardrails can be helpful!
When selecting a new AMS, I find my clients are often very tempted by custom software or "platform" systems (e.g., built on Salesforce or MS Dynamics) because these systems are infinitely configurable. After all, if I can make the system do anything I want, that's a good thing, right?
Well, maybe. In my experience, when associations are presented with the option of building anything they want, several things often happen:
- the scope and cost of the project balloons rapidly;
- many ideas are attempted and fail, at great cost of time and money;
- staff is often paralyzed with indecision about how to approach a particular challenge, how to prioritize, etc.
This is why, for many associations, a proprietary system purpose-built for association management can be a better choice, because these systems, by design, present "guardrails" to the association. While many are highly configurable, they are typically not infinitely customizable, which means there are some things you simply can't do with them.
Like all things, there are trade-offs. The guardrails may keep you from doing something you really need to do. But they may also help keep you focused, reducing costs and headaches.
This isn't to say customizable systems are a bad choice. For some associations they will make perfect sense. But for many associations, those guardrails serve an important purpose, and one many associations will find very valuable (if not also limiting!).
![]()
Wes's Wednesday Wisdom Archives
Either you test, or your members will
Either you test, or your members will If I was forced to choose the single […]
But are you really willing to change?
But are you really willing to change? When any organization is making a change in data management […]
Two tips for data conversion
Two Tips for Data Conversion I’ve written a lot about data conversion over the years […]
Who should “own” the database?
Who should “own” the database? One of the most common questions I get from my […]
What makes you weird?
What makes you weird? When I work with clients on selecting a new association management system, one […]
Why “AMS Consortiums” Don’t Work
Why “AMS Consortiums” Don’t Work About once a year I will get a call from […]
Your vendor will disappoint you
Your vendor will disappoint you I follow politics as a hobby. A past publisher from […]
Learn how to lose
Learn how to lose “Winning is great, sure, but if you are really going to […]
Ownership is Required
Ownership is required When asked for the most common reason AMS implementations fail, I typically respond […]
It’s all relative…
It’s all relative… Over the course of my 22 years of consulting, I’ve consulted with […]
