Guardrails can be helpful!
When selecting a new AMS, I find my clients are often very tempted by custom software or "platform" systems (e.g., built on Salesforce or MS Dynamics) because these systems are infinitely configurable. After all, if I can make the system do anything I want, that's a good thing, right?
Well, maybe. In my experience, when associations are presented with the option of building anything they want, several things often happen:
- the scope and cost of the project balloons rapidly;
- many ideas are attempted and fail, at great cost of time and money;
- staff is often paralyzed with indecision about how to approach a particular challenge, how to prioritize, etc.
This is why, for many associations, a proprietary system purpose-built for association management can be a better choice, because these systems, by design, present "guardrails" to the association. While many are highly configurable, they are typically not infinitely customizable, which means there are some things you simply can't do with them.
Like all things, there are trade-offs. The guardrails may keep you from doing something you really need to do. But they may also help keep you focused, reducing costs and headaches.
This isn't to say customizable systems are a bad choice. For some associations they will make perfect sense. But for many associations, those guardrails serve an important purpose, and one many associations will find very valuable (if not also limiting!).
![]()
Wes's Wednesday Wisdom Archives
Ask your members to update their info
Ask your members to update their info One of the greatest data management challenges any association […]
Customer vs. staff
Customer vs. staff In a properly designed AMS, when the customer goes online to your […]
Measuring customer service
Measuring customer service When I work with clients on AMS selection, one question that often […]
Iterate or innovate?
Iterate or innovate? When moving to a new association management system, there is often an implicit […]
Who is in control?
Who is in control? Speaking with a client once about their database project, the client […]
Sometimes Staff Has to do the Work
Sometimes staff has to do the work… As a child, I was attracted to computers […]
Documentation and the Great Resignation
Documentation and the Great Resignation Unless you’ve been living under the proverbial rock, you’ve heard […]
Data Management Strategy
Data Management Strategy Do you know what your data management strategy is? If you have […]
It’s always about trust
It’s always about trust When I work with clients on almost any data management project, […]
You can’t outsource buy-in
You can’t outsource buy-in One factor consistent with all of my most successful projects is […]
